Reply
Visitor
stardust_jerry
Posts: 6
Registered: 04-06-2011
Accepted Solution

MOTODEV versus vanilla Eclipse

I'm new to the MOTODEV forums.   I'm currently using standard Eclipse with the Android plugin and sdk.   Are there good advantages to using the MOTODEV version of Eclipse?   Also,  if one uses that version can apps be created that will still run on non-Motorola devices?   

 

 

-jerry
Please use plain text.
Contributor
osde8info
Posts: 21
Registered: 12-05-2010

Re: MOTODEV versus vanilla Eclipse

YES but you can also install the motodev plugin into your existing eclipse ! 

 

i love motodev android app and android widg builders and then android emulator in an eclipse tab that you can actually zoom in and out of and rotate ! BUT apparently they are dropping that feature very soon !

regards clive
Please use plain text.
Visitor
stardust_jerry
Posts: 6
Registered: 04-06-2011

Re: MOTODEV versus vanilla Eclipse

Thanks Clive.  I'll give the MOTODEV plug-in a whirl.

 

-jerry

-jerry
Please use plain text.
Motorola
EricC
Posts: 491
Registered: 08-19-2008

Re: MOTODEV versus vanilla Eclipse

 


osde8info wrote:

YES but you can also install the motodev plugin into your existing eclipse ! 

 

i love motodev android app and android widg builders and then android emulator in an eclipse tab that you can actually zoom in and out of and rotate ! BUT apparently they are dropping that feature very soon !


Sorry, for some reason this thread eluded my x-ray vision. :-)

 

 

Jerry, there is no lock-in or lock-out with MOTODEV Studio. If you try it and like it, we would love to have you on board. If you find that it's not to your liking, you can always switch to the same version of Eclipse (Helios SR1 currently) and your workspace and projects will continue to build just fine. You can build apps for any device, not just Motorola. If it leads to happy and productive developers who write great apps, we're hoping it drives consumers to choose our products in the marketplace. That's our motivation.

 

Clive, what feature are you referring to? We're not deprecating any feature any time soon that I'm aware of. You can embed or detach the emulator by simply choosing to display the view from the Window menu. It's true you can detach it and I find I prefer it that way, but you can move it about at will. 

 

The one place where we're having problems with the OS keeping up is on 32-bit Mac OS. The upcoming release, version 2.2, will likely be the 32-bit last version running 10.5. After that, it will be all 64-bit and 10.6 or greater. For Mac OS X only. Windows and Linux will continue to ship as both 32- and 64-bit.

 

Cheers

 

-E

--
Eric Cloninger
Product Line Manager
Eclipse Sequoyah Project Lead
Please use plain text.
Contributor
osde8info
Posts: 21
Registered: 12-05-2010

Re: MOTODEV versus vanilla Eclipse

i think you said that you were removing the android sdk installer from inside of motodev ?

 

i havent had a chance  to uninstall the java 32bit jdk and motodev studio and android sdk and reinstall java 64bit jdk and android sdk and motodev studio yet so am unable to confirm that all those lovely extra integrated android sdk motodev studio features would still work in this alternative configuration

regards clive
Please use plain text.
Motorola
EricC
Posts: 491
Registered: 08-19-2008

Re: MOTODEV versus vanilla Eclipse

 


osde8info wrote:

i think you said that you were removing the android sdk installer from inside of motodev ?

 


 

Ah, yes. That is true.  The SDK download piece was something that we put into MOTODEV Studio long before there was an Android SDK and AVD Manager. We felt it was a benefit to our users. When the ADT plugins added similar functionality, we did not feel it was necessary to continue providing a competing feature. The functionality is still in the tools, it's just a matter of where it is coming from.

 

I was reading your post and it appeared to me that you were talking about the emulator view.

--
Eric Cloninger
Product Line Manager
Eclipse Sequoyah Project Lead
Please use plain text.
Contributor
osde8info
Posts: 21
Registered: 12-05-2010

Re: MOTODEV versus vanilla Eclipse

thanks i have now uninstalled everything and reinstalled everything with the android sdk outside of the motodev tree and i can confirm you can still run android emulator inside a motodev window

regards clive
Please use plain text.